The Top 10: Celebrating the Songs of Prior Winners
Curtis Finch, Jr. "I Believe" by Fantasia Barrino
I'm jealous of Nicki Minaj for not having to watch that. There was absolutely nothing redeeming about that performance. Ho boy. Ho boy.
Janelle Arthur "Gone" by Montgomery Gentry (done by Scotty McCreery)
Pretty much as good as this could have been, given the arrangement. This is not the type of country music Janelle should be doing. Had she re-worked the song a little bit into what she does, this would probably be better... instead, it came off as forced karaoke.
Devin Velez "Temporary Home" by Carrie Underwood
Ho boy. Devin says he wants to prove he "can do more than just the ballads"... by doing a ballad? This really isn't my favorite Carrie Underwood song, and I like it even less when it's done in the style of a second-rate lounge singer.
Angie Miller "I Surrender" by Celine Dion (done by Kelly Clarkson)
Ugh. Celine. I get this performance... I do. Angie surely wants to show she doesn't need to be at the piano, and that she can be a powerhouse vocalist. The problem is that she really does need to be at the piano, and she really isn't a 'plant your feet and belt your face off' kind of singer. This performance was rather sleepy and came across rather forced. Unfortunate.
Paul Jolley "Amazed" by Lonestar (done by Scotty McCreery)
I really love Paul's tone, but so far his vocals really haven't been quite there... and this is more of that. The song choice is horrible (as it always is). Also, Jimmy Iovine using the whole Broadway singing thing as an insult? C'mon now. Let's just say it... Paul comes off a bit too flamboyant for country music.
Candice Glover "I Who Have Nothing" by Ben E. King (done by Jordin Sparks)
HOT DAMN.
Lazaro Arbos "Breakaway" by Kelly Clarkson
I really, really like Lazaro. I'm pretty sure it's impossible not to. But that was pretty bad. I really hate to say this, but it's kind of stating the obvious: I'd be really surprised if he's not, at best, the bottom 2 survivor tomorrow.
Kree Harrison "Crying" by Roy Orbison (done by Carrie Underwood)
Kree's tone is an absolute thing of beauty. The upper notes at the end of the song weren't as strong as the rest of it, but that's totally fine. It's only the top 10, but this already seems like a two-horse race. Sidenote: this would have been a good song for Janelle to do.
Burnell Taylor "Flying Without Wings" by Westlife (done by Ruben Studdard)
I'm sorry. If I'm being completely honest, I zoned out for the duration of this performance... just like I did for all of Ruben Studdard in season 2. Perhaps there's a connection.
Amber Holcomb "A Moment Like This" by Kelly Clarkson
The end of the intro package was about how Amber wants to make this song into her own... she does it by runs and rushing through it. Well played. It was alright. The top notes were a bit yelly, but maybe it's just me.
Wrap-Up
Two requests from the Idol producers:- Please choose new themes. I'm aware this is a new theme... but it's a theme that demanded contestant rehash "Idol standards". Come on, man. Or, at the very least, create a banned songs list. Please.
- Please set up a live camera on Mariah Carey at all times. The looks on her face when Nicki says/does Nicki things? Absolutely incredible.
Timm's Votes
Candice - 25
Kree - 20
Paul - 5
Candice slayed a beast of a song, Kree rocked, and I like Paul. My votes are pretty straightforward. Done and done.
